Study Guides/Civics/Why Power Sharing is Desirable
Study Guide ยท Civics

Why is Power Sharing Desirable? (Class 10 Civics)

In Class 10 Political Science (Power Sharing), we learn that democracies can be organized in many ways โ€” but the most stable and just democracies are those that share power rather than concentrate it. Why is this not just a nice idea, but a genuinely desirable and necessary arrangement?

Question (Click to Flip)

What is the difference between prudential and moral reasons?

Answer

Prudential = based on self-interest and calculating consequences ('we share power because it prevents conflict and keeps us stable'). Moral = based on principles and rights ('we share power because it is the right thing to do regardless of consequences').

Card 1 of 1 free previews

Key Facts

'Checks and Balances' is the system where different branches of government (Legislature, Executive, Judiciary) each have power over the others, preventing any single branch from becoming tyrannical. This is power sharing within the government itself.

Two Types of Reasons for Power Sharing

Political scientists give two distinct categories of reasons why power sharing is desirable:

1. Prudential Reasons (Practical/Pragmatic)

Prudential reasons are based on calculating long-term good consequences โ€” what is practically wise and beneficial.

Reduces conflict: When power is concentrated in one group, other communities feel excluded and resentful. This resentment leads to social conflict, unrest, and sometimes civil war.

Example โ€” Sri Lanka: The Sinhala majority gave themselves all power (language, government jobs, education) after independence. The Tamil minority felt completely excluded. This led to a brutal 30-year civil war (1983โ€“2009) that killed over 100,000 people and devastated the economy.

Provides stability: Power sharing brings all major groups into the system. Even if they disagree, they work out differences peacefully within the political framework rather than through violence.

2. Moral Reasons (Based on Values and Principles)

Moral reasons are based on what is inherently right, regardless of outcomes.

Democracy itself requires it: Power sharing is the very spirit of democracy. A system where citizens have no say in how they are governed is not a democracy โ€” it is an oligarchy or dictatorship.

Equal dignity: Every citizen, regardless of their community, religion, or language, has an equal right to participate in governance. Denying this is morally wrong.

Example โ€” Belgium: Belgium avoided conflict by cleverly designing a power-sharing constitution that gave equal representation to Dutch-speaking Flemish and French-speaking Walloon communities.

Questions and Answers

What is the difference between prudential and moral reasons?+

**Prudential** = based on self-interest and calculating consequences ('we share power because it prevents conflict and keeps us stable'). **Moral** = based on principles and rights ('we share power because it is the right thing to do regardless of consequences').

More in Civics

Study Smarter with Shinyu.ai

Turn this guide into revision flashcards, a practice exam, or an AI-generated podcast โ€” free, no signup required.