Study Guides/English/What kind of teachers did Margie and Tommy have
Study Guide ยท English

What Kind of Teachers did Margie and Tommy Have?

In the futuristic Class 9 English story 'The Fun They Had' by Isaac Asimov (set in 2157), school as we know it no longer exists. Instead of walking to a school building to meet a teacher, children like Margie and Tommy have a very different kind of teacher at home.

Question (Click to Flip)

Why was Tommy's mechanical teacher taken away for repair?

Answer

Tommy's teacher had been malfunctioning โ€” his Geography sector had been set too fast (at a level inappropriate for his age). A man came and took the teacher away for repairs, resetting it to the proper level.

Card 1 of 1 free previews

Key Facts

The mechanical teacher in the story prefigures modern AI tutoring systems and e-learning platforms! Asimov's 1951 vision of home-based robot teachers is remarkably close to today's adaptive AI learning tools.

The Mechanical Teacher

Margie and Tommy have Mechanical Teachers โ€” large, robotic teaching machines installed directly in their homes, in their bedrooms.

The mechanical teacher is described as:

  • Large and black with a big screen on which lessons were shown
  • It calculates student performance, gives tests, and grades them
  • It teaches all subjects โ€” Geography, History, Arithmetic
  • It operates at a fixed time every day โ€” the same time, without exception
  • It is programmed to give exactly the right level of questions for each pupil

Why Margie Hated Her Teacher

Margie hated her mechanical teacher intensely for several reasons:

  1. It gave her test after test in Geography and she was failing consistently
  2. It was impersonal and inflexible โ€” it didn't notice her struggles, didn't slow down, couldn't comfort her
  3. It operated at the same fixed time every day โ€” even if she was tired or unwell
  4. Her performance was automatically submitted to her parents โ€” no privacy

The Human Teacher โ€” A Lost Dream

When Margie and Tommy find an old book from centuries ago that describes human teachers, Margie is fascinated.

A human teacher was a real person who:

  • Taught children in a school building with other children present
  • Adjusted their teaching based on student responses
  • Could have a bad day, could be kind, could make mistakes

The story ends with Margie thinking wistfully about what real school was like โ€” laughing, learning together, and having a teacher who was a living person.

Questions and Answers

Why was Tommy's mechanical teacher taken away for repair?+

Tommy's teacher had been malfunctioning โ€” his **Geography sector** had been set too fast (at a level inappropriate for his age). A man came and took the teacher away for repairs, resetting it to the proper level.

More in English

Study Smarter with Shinyu.ai

Turn this guide into revision flashcards, a practice exam, or an AI-generated podcast โ€” free, no signup required.